Tucked away on Lippert Hollow Road in Allegany, New York, this unusual property offers something rare: a chance to start almost completely from scratch. Sitting on 1.3 wooded acres near Rock City Park, the cottage is listed with three bedrooms but is “fully gutted, not move-in ready.” Instead of a polished home, buyers get an unfinished structure surrounded by trees, privacy, and plenty of potential.
Inside, the house has been stripped down to its framing. Floors are exposed, and many systems are missing or incomplete, making it clear that serious renovation will be required. Yet the front porch remains, along with a wood stove that serves as a reminder that the cottage once had warmth and life. Some important groundwork has also been completed, including French drains around the exterior and reinforced supports, suggesting that previous work had already begun.
The wooded setting may be the property’s biggest attraction. Tall trees surround the clearing, creating a quiet and private atmosphere near the natural beauty of Rock City Park. The property also includes an outhouse, adding to its rustic character and making it clear that this is not a modern, ready-to-live-in home.
At an asking price of $37,500, this is less a purchase of comfort than “a purchase of possibility.” The low price comes with a major trade-off: time, money, patience, and plenty of renovation work. Whoever takes on the project will have to rebuild the home while making nearly every major design decision themselves.
For some buyers, that challenge may be exactly what makes it appealing. “Not everything valuable begins complete.” The cottage may be unfinished today, but for someone with vision, it could eventually become a private retreat shaped entirely around their own ideas.
